Top Design Tips for Creating Custom Police Challenge Coins

challenge coin
July 21, 2025
Top Design Tips for Creating Custom Police Challenge Coins

Police challenge coins are more than just pieces of metal — they’re a symbol of honor, pride and purpose. Whether it’s designed to award exceptional service or commemorate a major milestone, every coin tells a story. And the best part? You get to help write that story.

At Galaxy Design Squad, we believe that custom challenge coins should be as bold and meaningful as the people who carry them. From department mottos to symbols that reflect your values, we’ll help you design a coin that stands out. Ready to get started? Check out our top design tips for police coins!

 

Understanding the Purpose of Your Police Challenge Coin

If there’s one thing that every great police coin needs, it’s a great purpose. In other words, what are you looking to get from your custom challenge coins?

Maybe you want to boost unit pride by creating a custom token that your team can share. Maybe you’re celebrating years of service, recognizing the dedication and grit it takes to protect your community. Or perhaps it’s a memorial coin, designed to pay tribute to a department hero.

Whatever your mission is, the goal is the same: create a tangible, high-quality token that people will treasure. By outlining the purpose of your police challenge coin, you can ensure that the final design achieves this goal.

 

Choosing the Right Shape, Size and Finish for Maximum Impact

While purpose is undeniably important, a huge part of any police challenge coin is how it looks and feels. With the right design choices, you can make sure your police coin stands out.

Start with the shape. Round coins may be traditional, but that doesn’t mean they have to be boring. Spruce up your coin with a unique edge, such as a rope or reeded design. Want something truly outside the box? Create a custom shape that embodies your department, such as a badge, star or shield.

Next, consider the size. Most coins fall between 1.5″ and 2″ — however, if you really want that wow factor, you’re welcome to make them bigger. Larger coins can also accommodate more imagery or words.

Last but not least, think about the finish. Want something bold and colorful? Hard or soft enamel can add depth and vibrancy. Prefer a more sleek, professional vibe? Antique silver, gold or black nickel plating can deliver an elegant feel.

 

Symbols, Logos, and Text: Making It Meaningful

Now that you’ve nailed the perfect design, it’s time to integrate your coin’s purpose.

Want to build unit pride? Including your unit’s motto or an inside joke is a great way to build camaraderie. You can even take it a step further by featuring unique imagery, such as your department’s official badge or emblem.

Honoring someone’s service? Customize the coin with the officer’s rank, name and years of service. If you’re celebrating a specific milestone, such as a promotion or anniversary, you can highlight the date or event title. If you’re creating a memorial coin, honor the fallen officer with their badge number, name or an inspirational quote.

Ultimately, the goal is to impart meaning. The right symbols, logos and text can transform a generic police challenge coin into a one-of-a-kind keepsake that your team will value for years to come.

 

Color Psychology and Design Aesthetics in Law Enforcement Coins

During the design process, it’s important not to underestimate the importance of color. Your chosen colors are more than a decorative choice — they’re a form of communication. The right colors should evoke emotion, reflect your department’s identity and set your coin apart.

Let’s start with the classics: blue. Not only does blue represent police forces, but it also conveys professionalism and trust. Traditional designs pair blue with silver (which offers a clean, modern look) or gold (which is a bit bolder and more ceremonial).

If you’re looking to promote unity and strength, you might want to try a black accent. A black and blue combination also carries emotional weight, which is why it’s commonly used to honor fallen officers or major milestones.

For something a little more “out there,” consider integrating a bright color like orange or green. Orange often symbolizes energy and strength, while green can represent nature and sustainability (which is great for rural departments).

 

Why Galaxy Design Squad Is the Trusted Partner for Custom Police Coins

When it comes to designing custom police challenge coins, you want something that captures the heart of your department. Something that looks sharp, feels good and tells your unique story. That’s where Galaxy Design Squad comes in.

We specialize in premium, custom-crafted police coins that strike the perfect balance between time-honored tradition and modern creativity. Whether you’re sticking with classic shapes or exploring bold colors and edges, our design experts will help bring your vision to life.

Interested in learning more? Contact us for a free quote today!

Related articles